True the extra $100 did not help PS3 during that time last gen but the situation is the same, poor public image, confusing marketing message, and price. MS fixed price but now they have to back pedal even faster to undo the rest...
I honestly wouldn't say it's the same. I mean it is similar in some ways but I wouldn't say that it's exactly the same. As I said before, the PS3 was $200 more and released a year after the 360. Sony didn't make significant changes to the PS3's branding/messaging until 2009 when the slim model came out. That was almost 3 years after the PS3 launch.
MS has made many changes to the Xbox One and in a pretty short time too. I can't think of any other console that has changed so much from the few months before it was released up to the half-way point of its first year. It releasing the same time as the PS4 has helped it too in terms of online userbase... well at least in America (which is what this thread is about). There were far more people on Xbox Live last gen. Now though things are pretty even (again, at least in America). Therefore, the cases of someone having more friends playing on PS4 over the Xbox One isn't close to being as frequent/large as the cases of people having more of their friends play on the Xbox 360 over the PS3 last gen. So I would say that in America that things are pretty even for both consoles when it comes to the "I'm getting this console to play with my friends online" type of influence. PS4 has a slight advantage since it has sold more in America but it isn't enough for it to be the obvious winner in America yet (like the Xbox 360 was last gen).
...I'm sorry but a Halo collection this fall wont save them, it going to take more then that. I am a firm believer that their problem is public perception.
It will take more than just that and it seems like MS knows it. They will have a seemingly pretty solid exclusive lineup for the Fall of this year. That combined with all of the multiplats will definitely cause the Xbox One to sell well in America this Fall/Xmas season.
One of the advantages of Xbox is that their exclusives are more multiplayer focused too. This therefore creates more "word of mouth" as these games usually get played by users for a longer period of time than single player games. So if they can have a decent number of new, solid exclusive multiplayer oriented games on top of the popular multiplats then they will be in a really good spot/position IMO.
__________________________________________________
Only half a million? It doesn't really matter if MS overtake or not then. If in 3 years time PS4 is sitting at 30 million and X1 is sitting at 28 million isn't that basically a draw?
Kind of... MS would still be thought of by some as the "loser" though due to them not having the same dominance in the US that they did last gen; well, at least against Playstation.
The biggest thing for MS has gotta be not falling behind significantly to the point that third parties aren't that interested in their system. Hopefully that doesn't happen.
Don't think that will ever happen. Sales show that Xbox One users actually buy a decent number of games (unlike the Wii U).
____________________
I can't see XB1 outselling the PS4 for months straight by 100k to 200k in the USA. That's what it's going to take.
Not really... unless this current gen will end in 2015.